May 15, 2024

Noise-making vs. Policy asks

In today’s posts, both Marc Gustafson and Esther Sprague point to the evolution of activism on Darfur from being focused on generating noise (what Gustafson terms “awareness campaigns”) to calling for specific policies (what Gustafson calls “advocacy campaigns”). Certainly when it comes to the SDC I see this transition as a struggle which played out […]

Questions for the advocacy community: Q2 – Marc Gustafson

Q2: Is citizen advocacy at its most effective when it generates maximum “noise” on an issue , or do citizen advocates need to attach particular policy prescriptions to the noise they make? Marc Gustafson: There can be no framework for measuring the efficacy of advocacy groups. Some are successful because they bring awareness to typically […]

Questions for the advocacy community: Q2 – Esther Sprague

Q2: Is citizen advocacy at its most effective when it generates maximum “noise” on an issue , or do citizen advocates need to attach particular policy prescriptions to the noise they make? Esther Sprague: I became a Darfur activist because a friend of mine, Mamer Kuer Ajak, was concerned about reports he was hearing concerning […]

Questions for the Advocacy Community – Part II

Hi everyone A series of interesting posts are coming up this week from Ruth Messinger, Nasredeen Abdulbari, Esther Sprague, Marc Gustafson, Erin Mazursky, Eric Reeves, Alex de Waal, John Norris and Jill Savitt on the question of  whether citizen advocacy at its most effective when it generates maximum “noise” on an issue , or whether […]

Questions for the advocacy community: Q2 – Nasredeen Abdulbari :الضجة مقابل السياسة السؤال رقم 2

Q2: Is citizen advocacy at its most effective when it generates maximum “noise” on an issue , or do citizen advocates need to attach particular policy prescriptions to the noise they make? Nasredeen Abdulbari: Politicians are usually pretty overwhelmed with their political activities and work, and rarely do they find time to lay down concrete […]

Questions for the advocacy community: Q2 – Ruth Messinger et al

Q2: Is citizen advocacy at its most effective when it generates maximum “noise” on an issue , or do citizen advocates need to attach particular policy prescriptions to the noise they make? Ruth Messinger, President, American Jewish World Service (AJWS); Ian Schwab, Senior Associate and National Grassroots Organizer at  AJWS; and Leah Kaplan Robins, Senior […]

Questions for the Advocacy Community

Hi everyone Below are the first posts in the “questions for the advocacy community” conversation I’ll be running on this site over the coming weeks. As more contributions come in, I’ll probably start commenting, but I would also love to hear what you think. In the posts on Q1, KTJ Scott and Alex de Waal […]

Q1: Alex de Waal

Q1: Can pressure from citizens ever add a foreign policy issue to the list of traditional national interests? Or can citizens only impact the sense of urgency around an issue that was already a traditional national interest to start with? Alex de Waal: Let me briefly look at two recent examples of how citizens’ activism […]

Q1: KTJ Scott

Q1: Can pressure from citizens ever add a foreign policy issue to the list of traditional national interests? Or can citizens only impact the sense of urgency around an issue that was already a traditional national interest to start with? KTJ Scott: I am not entirely certain what is included on the list of national […]

Perceptions from outside the U.S.

Hi everyone Another “ongoing conversation” I’m hoping to start this week is about how the U.S. based Darfur advocacy movement is perceived by people outside the U.S.  I’ve asked a few friends and colleagues from around the world who were selected as 2007 Global Young Leaders on Genocide Prevention, to contribute their thoughts. To start […]